So, the last I reported, Marie-Marthe was back in the hands of her abuser.
Literally was IN THE HANDS of Fifi (her abuser) before we left the courthouse.
This. made. me. livid.
It made Nick more livid. He lost his top a little. But not in a bad way. He went out into the road and screamed and pleaded with the parents not to do this. As they got on motos with Fifi and Marie-Marthe, he ran down the street chasing them begging them not to do what they were doing. He held up the pictures we'd shown in court. And he ran after her screaming and begging and calling Fifi out for what she had done.
Now this doesn't sound like the actions of someone who is all-together sane. But I honestly don't know that there has been a moment in our marriage when I was prouder of him. Nick will admit this was the first time in his life (or at least in a REALLY long time) that he's been moved to emotion like this
about something that mattered. I am sure this will come as a shock to you, but Nick and I
occasionally disagree about things. And this might also come as a shock to you but-- I can be, hem, spirited when I am mad. Another way to say it is that sometimes I am mean. Still others might say that I can be as mean as a rattlesnake when I am angry. And that tendency in me
sometimes brings out the worst in Nick's emotions. And when we went through a huge betrayal last year, Nick's emotions got the better of him at times. But it's never been like this before. It's never been out of compassion like in was in this case. (Don't take this as me cutting the legs out from under Nick, he'd agree with me.)
When we first got Marie-Marthe, Nick warned me not to get to attached to her. (Yeah, like I'd do
THAT! :) He reminded me that she was most likely temporary in our home and that we didn't have any rights to her for more than a few days. And so, as if to prove it to Nick that I
could do what he was asking, I did. I kept her at an arm's length. I comforted her when she cried, but I also was REALLY careful to try not to absorb (or even think about) her situation.
Then the evening before we went to court I called Nick on the phone as I was heading home from my Bible study and he was a wreck. I asked him what was wrong and he said, "Gwenn, this is a little girl. She's just a little girl and we had better damn-well fight our hardest to make sure she stays safe." (Sorry for the swear word-- I think it doesn't count if it's in a quote, right? )
And I said, "Nick, I get what you're saying, but remember what you told me. We probably won't have any option to keep her. We need to guard our hearts."
And Nick said, "No. Gwenn, she is just a little girl. She was crying on and off today and telling me and the little girls some of her story. And I was comforting her and as she was collapsed in a pile of tears in my arms and I really started looking at her. Her arms, her legs, her face. The are all covered in scars. Oh, Gwenn. She's just a little girl. This may be her only chance. We had better do everything we can to protect her."
I got home a few minutes later and I just sat with Nick while he processed the fact that finally, after two years he (in his own words) "grew a heart."
And then it didn't work out the way we'd hoped in court. We'd hoped her parents would feel the same righteous anger for what had been done to their daughter as we did. But that didn't happen. That morning we'd left the house really hoping that Marie-Marthe would have a happy reunion with her parents. But then when they showed up to court, they showed up with Fifi. And it went from this case where the parents had put out a summons to have Fifi deposed about what they'd done to their daughter, to them being on the same side as Fifi and fighting us to return Marie Marthe. We made it clear we had no intentions of trying to "steal" their daughter, she was merely brought to us and we felt compelled to try to help her.
The court case was a joke. We hardly got the chance to talk. Fifi had a lawyer. We didn't even know we needed a lawyer. The lawyer claimed we were just these blan (foreign) interlopers coming to Haiti to cause problems and that we should have our organization revoked and be deported. Now, let me be clear. We were never in danger of that happening. The judge agreed that we have a right to be here and involved in the situation. He agreed that what had been done to Marie-Marthe was wrong.
It was so hard to be there while Marie-Marthe was there sitting right beside us. Everyone was talking about her as if she wasn't sitting right there. And nearly the whole time we were there, Marie-Marthe had her head buried with her eyes shut super-tight and she was plugging her ears so she didn't have to hear what was happening.
So then came this time where he made Marie-Marthe stand up and I thought he was going to ask her to tell her side of what had happened. But he didn't. He just told her to walk to her parents. He told us he was signing an order putting her back in the hands of her parents and signing another order saying we were within our rights to have her for the time we did and not liable for anything that might happen in the future.
And then, just like that, it was over.
I was kind of stunned. Tears sprung to my eyes and I respectfully asked to judge what was going to be done about Fifi. She'd abused this child repeatedly for the past 3 years. He said, "Don't worry, you're not liable for this." And I told him that I wasn't concerned about our liability but I was worried about Marie-Marthe. I was afraid if she stayed with the parents she was going to end back up in the hands of this woman who'd abused her. He basically said, "Yeah, it's the parents' choice. They can do what they want to do with her. You don't have any claim to her."
And then he stood up and walked away. And Marie-Marthe and her mom and dad and Fifi all weaved their way through the crowd. (Cause this is Haiti so people come down to the courthouse to listen to cases as entertainment.) And then when I realized it was over, I started crying. And Nick started getting upset. And I said, "Nick, follow her. We can't let her end back up in Fifi's hands." And Nick weaved his way through the crowd after them while I slipped out the side door to get some air (because I really felt like I was going to be sick.)
And now we've come full circle in the story. Nick begs the parents to (as I mentioned) to no avail. They all leave together. Nick walks back into the courtroom and finds the judge and tells him that Fifi was holding Marie-Marthe by the arms before they left and then they all left together. The judge was kind of taken aback, but kind of not surprised all at the same time.
Nick saw that I was breaking and he put me in the truck and we rode home and I just lost it. I was crying and screaming and yelling and snotting everywhere. And I was punching the door and banging my head against the window. My heart ached. The only other time I remember feeling grief emotions this strong was the night we learned that Josiah was going to need heart surgery. And because of a mis-communication between us and the doctors, Nick and I both thought they were saying he was going to die. That was resolved after about an hour or so, but that was one of the worst hours of my life. My heart felt as if it couldn't stand emotions so strong.
Later on that day, I got a call from a friend (the same one who'd brought this situation to our attention) that one of her friends is family with Fifi and she'd gone over to her house and Marie-Marthe was there. We knew that had probably happened, but now we had confirmation.
The next day I laid in bed all day. I didn't feel anything except ache. The day after, I decided I had to see Marie-Marthe again. I had put together a backpack of stuff before we went to court-- clothes and toys and hygiene products but then they left so fast she never got it. So I reasoned that I could stop by Fifi's house and ask to see Marie-Marthe so I could give her the backpack.
I drove up. Her gate was open. I went into the yard. There were a bunch of kids there. I didn't see Marie-Marthe, but in just a minute Fifi came out of the house and asked me what I was doing there. (Fair question.) I told her I had some stuff for Marie-Marthe that she'd left in the car and I wanted to give it to her. Now, I reasoned this was okay because --a. I was in denial. And -- b. The mom DID tell me (early on in the process) that I could visit her after the fact.
Fifi said Marie-Marthe wasn't there and told me I could go. She wasn't real mean about it, just kind of matter of fact. I tried to ask more questions about her location but it she wasn't interested in talking.
So I left.
The next day I spent nearly the whole day in bed again. (I am not claiming that was an emotionally stable thing to do, but honestly, my nerves are somewhat shot these days and I just didn't know what else to do.)
And then the day after, (or was it the day after that?) I went to back Fifi's house with the bag of stuff. This time, the neighbor (who shares a yard with Fifi) saw me coming and slammed the door in my face. Reasoning that I wasn't there to see her, but someone else who shared that gate, I knocked. And she told me to go away. And I knocked some more and I said that I had some stuff I wanted to give to Marie-Marthe. And she came out and yelled at me and told me to keep the stuff and to go away and never come back. Fifi came out at this point and she was angry too. She said Marie-Marthe wasn't there anymore and that I needed to leave. I realized there was nothing I could do-- no way I could know if Marie-Marthe was really there or not. And I also realized that I had two angry women in front of me and at least one of them is mean enough to abuse a kid. Wisdom started to overshadow denial at this point. And so I walked back to the car.
After we left I asked Hugues call to Marie Marthe's sister to find out if she knew where Marie-Marthe was. (We'd kind of made friends with her during the process.) She claimed that the parents had taken her away somewhere far. I was hopeful that was the case, but I didn't really believe it.
Later in the day, Hugues was in the market and ran into Marie-Marthe's mother (she's a water vendor.) He asked where Marie-Marthe was and she said that the father had taken her away somewhere far away. So I called my friend who lives near Marie-Marthe to ask if she had any information. She asked around and found out that Fifi had been doing a lot of the chores Marie-Marthe had been doing-- cleaning and shopping. She also said that no one had seen Marie-Marthe in about 2 days.
So. We don't really know what happened, but it APPEARS that Marie-Marthe is no longer with Fifi. That's what we're hoping anyway. We just don't know.
We all still really miss Marie-Marthe. I've been praying for her regularly.
I really hope it's working out well. But I get it. I know how these things usually work.
And if I am going to be honest, the thought that keeps haunting me is this-- with the amount of abuse she'd sustained, we were extremely surprised to find out (based on her words and a physical examination by a healthcare professional) that it appeared she hadn't ever been sexually violated. SO MANY girls/young women here are sexually abused. In my opinion, it's one of the biggest social problems facing girls/women in Haiti. And that was this one little tiny thing I kept clinging to in my spirit-- at least she hasn't been raped. This tiny little sliver of wholeness and dignity that she was permitted to keep.
And now... who knows? And I about can't breathe every time I think about it too much.
One thing Nick said to me during this was, "I don't want Marie-Marthe to be that story in our heads-- you know what I mean, the story we have about how our eyes got open to the plight of restavek children." But sadly, that's happened.
I love/hate this picture of Nick with Marie-Marthe. We were just about to leave for court and we were saying our goodbyes. In this picture it's so clear in Nick's face that he knew. He knew. He was hopeful-- we were both hopeful, but he knew what was about to happen.

I know that I am not God. I know I cannot control what happens to Marie-Marthe. I know I am probably never going to see her again. And I know that some would claim that this is "not my problem" (like the judge said, and like the emails that I know I will receive from readers who think I am misguided in my intentions to work towards solutions in a place like Haiti.)
But I guess my question is this, if I think Jesus is pretty serious about people who cause children harm (see Luke 17:1-2) and I claim to be a follower of Jesus-- WHY
isn't this my problem?
And honestly, if you claim to be a follower of Jesus, why isn't this
your problem?